MAC Petticoat Mineralize Skinfinish Comparison-The Old and New

When MAC Petticoat Mineralize Skinfinish was re-released with the In The Groove Collection, I was pretty sure that I already had it somewhere in my makeup stash. The problem: I couldn’t find it. So I ordered another one.


Of course when my MAC ordered arrived, I found my original MAC Petticoat at the bottom of my drawer. When I opened it, it looked a little different from the new one. Take a look:

On the left is the new MAC Petticoat MSF and on the right is the old one. 
They really changed the veining on the new one! More fine veins of the darker burgundy colour are in the new one. But does it look different when swatched?
The swatch on the left is the old MAC Petticoat MSF, while the right swatch is the new one. The old one is a tad darker than the new one. And to tell you the truth, it felt smoother when I swatched it too-it just glided a bit better than the new Petticoat. 

Both versions are great, but the old one is just a tiny bit better. Which makes me wonder if the same goes for the Infamous Stereo Rose MSF? I wonder it the original was just a tad bit better too? I sure wish I had on original for comparison. Although I love my Stereo Rose so much I can’t imagine it being any better than it already is. But was it?
Share: